Back to Bigger Picture

BIGGER PICTURE Public & everyday services

A driverless-car safety claim checked against insurance records

The important question about a robotaxi is not whether it looks futuristic. It is whether people outside and inside the vehicle face less harm. A Waymo–Swiss Re study used liability claims to make that question measurable.

A white Waymo Jaguar I-Pace with roof sensors driving on a San Francisco street.Original photograph
An actual Waymo Jaguar I-Pace photographed in San Francisco in November 2023. The photograph shows the vehicle platform, not an insurance event.Dllu / Wikimedia CommonsCC BY 4.0
Historical dataset
25.3 million driverless miles, through July 2024
Property damage
88% fewer liability claims than the baseline
Bodily injury
92% fewer liability claims than the baseline

How the idea works

  1. Sense the whole road scene

    Cameras, lidar and radar describe surrounding traffic.

  2. Predict and plan movement

    Onboard software identifies objects and chooses a driving path.

  3. Audit real-world outcomes

    Liability claims are compared with geographically calibrated human exposure.

A continuous view around the vehicle

Waymo combines cameras, lidar and radar with onboard computation. The sensors contribute complementary information about surroundings, distance and motion; software identifies road users and plans vehicle movement. This mechanism can support safer driving, but a technical description alone cannot establish that it does. The claim must be tested against what happens on roads.

Sources: [3]

Compare like places and driving exposure

Swiss Re and Waymo examined 25.3 million fully autonomous miles from January 2018 through July 2024 in four US operating areas. They calibrated human-driver insurance benchmarks to geography and mileage. The approach asked about liability claims, a proxy for responsibility in harmful collisions, rather than comparing a robotaxi demonstration with a national headline statistic.

Sources: [1]

Nine property claims and two injury claims

The study reported nine property-damage and two bodily-injury claims in the Waymo dataset, compared with approximately 78 and 26 expected from its overall human benchmark. Those differences correspond to reductions of 88% and 92%. At the reporting date, the two injury claims were still open. These are claims counts, not a count of every collision.

Sources: [2]

Strong evidence needs a defined boundary

This company-linked observational study supports a safety benefit within the studied operations. It does not prove safety on every road, in every weather condition or for every automated-driving system. Its most useful example is methodological: publish exposure, comparison rules and harm-related outcomes, so optimism can be examined rather than accepted on appearance.

Sources: [1]

The original sources

  1. Swiss Re / Waymo study authorsDo Autonomous Vehicles Outperform Latest-Generation Human-Driven Vehicles? 25-million-mile analysis
  2. WaymoNew Swiss Re study: Waymo safety comparison
  3. WaymoSelf-Driving Car Technology: Waymo Driver

What to explore next

Seeing hunger grow before the next full surveyA few seconds of eardrum video make a difficult distinction visible
Explore all 99 applications