Back to Bigger Picture

BIGGER PICTURE Public & everyday services

50,000 public responses became a map analysts could inspect

Consult helped a water-sector review organize a mountain of public submissions. Its useful role was to create a first pass that people could check, correct and use for deeper analysis.

AI-generated illustration: Public-response cards organised into an inspectable map of themes.
Public-response cards organised into an inspectable map of themes. Conceptual illustration; not a photograph or an exact depiction of the real project.AI-generated illustration of the idea, not a photograph of the actual people, equipment or event.
Water review responses
>50,000
Automated categorization
About 2 hours
Expert checking
22 hours

How the idea works

  1. Collect the original responses

    Free-text submissions enter the analysis workflow.

  2. Map overlapping themes

    The model groups concerns without forcing one label per answer.

  3. Inspect and interpret

    Analysts check labels and develop the final analysis.

Listening can become a sorting bottleneck

Public consultations collect free-text responses, not neat database rows. People may describe the same concern in different language, or raise several issues in one answer. For the Independent Water Commission, more than 50,000 responses created a substantial organizing task before policy experts could examine the concerns and evidence in depth.

Sources: [1]

One answer can belong to several themes

The government’s transparency record explains that Consult uses language models to generate themes and assign responses to them. An answer can receive zero, one or several theme assignments. The output gives analysts an initial thematic landscape, with human review and relabelling built into the process. The aim is to organize public input, not manufacture public opinion.

Sources: [2]

Two hours was not the whole job

The October 2025 account reports around two hours of automated categorization, costing£240, followed by 22 hours of expert checking. Detailed manual review of stakeholder submissions also continued. These distinctions matter: the reported machine time covers sorting, not the entire consultation or final report. Staff used the organized material to focus on interpretation and recommendations.

Sources: [1]

Preserve the route back to people’s words

Theme assignment involves judgement, and the earlier evaluation found imperfect agreement among both humans and AI. Speed therefore cannot substitute for checking whether unusual or minority views survive the categorization. Consult’s promising contribution is reducing the initial organizational burden while preserving an analyst-led process. Projected savings across government remain projections, separate from this documented application.

Sources: [2][1]

The original sources

  1. UK GovernmentConsult supports Independent Water Commission response analysis
  2. UK GovernmentDSIT: Consult algorithmic transparency record

What to explore next

The bank sees a scam before the money leavesTeaching AI to invent a shorter way to multiply
Explore all 99 applications